• Become a member
  • Log In
The Institution of Electronics
  • Home
  • About us
    • Our Objectives
    • Our History
    • Governance of the Institution
  • The Electron Magazine
    • 2024
      • 2024 – Winter
      • 2024 – Spring
      • 2024 – Summer
      • 2024 – Autumn
    • 2025
      • 2025 – Winter
      • 2025 – Spring
      • 2025 – Summer
      • 2025 – Autumn
    • 2026
      • 2026 – Winter
      • 2026 – Summer
  • Members
    • Membership Grades and Fees
    • Members’ Resources
      • The Electron Newsletter
      • The Archives
  • Education and Projects
    • National Electronics Competition
    • Student Members’ Projects
    • Arkwright Engineering Scholarships
  • News
  • Contact Us
  • Menu Menu
Uncategorised

When an energy-efficient design meets harsh reality

The Copenhagen wheel was an impressive attempt to retroactively electrify the standard bicycle, but reality got in the way.

I was recently browsing some news stories on the popularity of electric-assist bikes (e-bikes) and came across a name I hadn’t heard in a few years: “Copenhagen Wheel.”

What’s that, you wonder? It was an ambitious design of a replacement rear wheel for any standard bicycle. Take off your rear wheel, put the Copenhagen wheel on instead, and you would have a motor-assisted electric bicycle that offered pedal assist when its torque sensor decided you needed some help (Figure 1). It was truly a “drop-in” upgrade.


Figure 1 The Copenhagen Wheel was an innovative design, putting all the functions needed – and more – for an electric-assist bike in a sophisticated, smart hub of a replacement rear wheel. (Image source: ExtremeTech/Ziff Davis)

The Copenhagen Wheel was developed at MIT’s Senseable City Lab in partnership with the city of Copenhagen, and unveiled at the 2009 United Nations Climate Change Conference with a $1000 target price. It became commercially available in October 2017 at around $1800 (yes, that is a long prototype-to-production time and price bounce).

When it was formally introduced at that world-wide environmental conference, it received an enormous amount of media attention and hype. The words “revolutionary” and “seamless” were casually tossed around in much of the media coverage.

And why not, as it had all the right pieces, beginning with that clever name, the MIT connection, and the “green” environmental glow. It was going to change urban and suburban personal mobility for the better, everywhere. The Senseable City Lab project soon became the stand-alone company Superpedestrian, Inc.

The Copenhagen Wheel consisted of a custom brushless motor, advanced sensors, control systems, GPS, and a lithium-ion battery, all enclosed within the red rear-wheel hub. The control system interfaced with a range of sensors measuring actual torque, power, cadence, pedal position, and acceleration to monitor a rider’s effort when pedaling. The Wheel responded to a rider’s inputs by providing the appropriate level of assistance at each moment, creating what was claimed to be a seamless ride experience

Unlike many low-end e-bikes of the time, or DIY conversion that had the motor, control unit, and battery as separate components mounted on different parts of the bike and wired together, the Copenhagen Wheel combined all of those pieces (with the exception of the controls, which was your phone) right into its signature red hub (Figure 2). It weighed just 13 pounds (6 kilograms), which was an impressive achievement.


Figure 2 The assembly of the Copenhagen Wheel packed a lot of electrical and mechanical hardware into a small, tightly-constrained disk space between the bike’s drive hub and wheel’s spokes. (Image source: ExtremeTech/Ziff Davis)

Although the concept seems simple enough, a layout of the parts on the bill of materials shows some of its many unique static and moving parts (Figure 3).


Figure 3 Many specialized mechanical parts are required to build a self-contained, powered add-on for a bicycle. (Image source: The Vintagent)

The brushless motor was rated at 350 watts for the US market, and 250 W for Europe (due to EU standards restriction), leading to a top speed of 20 mph (US) and 25 km/hr (Europe—again, due to standards restriction). The 48-V lithium battery (watt-hours not specified) was rated for 1000 charge cycles, with a recharge time of 4 hours. Range was claimed to be up to 31 miles (40 km). And it also had regenerative braking – another “green” plus.

The overall design offered many features. It was locked/unlocked via the user’s phone’s Bluetooth link. The smart torque-sensing system only added pedaling assist as needed. It also recorded distance and travel route (at users’ option) to hopefully help urban planners better understand who was going where, how, and when.

Then, reality intruded

Unfortunately, the harsh reality of production and outdoor cycling became obstacles. There were quality problems, customer-support issues, and perhaps most worrisome, bearing failures to due water ingress (which, after all, is to be expected on a bicycle). There were also software issues with various bugs and even cases where the Bluetooth link did not unlock the bike. The fairy tale story had an unpleasant end, and Superpedestrian, Inc. closed down in 2020.

I’m not criticizing the design, its many challenges, the media-driven “lovefest” or the subsequent failure. It’s very easy to gloat or do a snarky, hindsight-driven critique while sitting at a desk. I admire the developers’ ambition and multifaceted hardware (electrical and mechanical) and software creation, and how far they got.

That said, I do wonder about two minor aspects of the design. The reliance on the phone to be the “key” to unlocking and using the bike meant that users were wholly dependent on that link, which always has me a little uncomfortable. Also, I wonder if adding regenerative braking – a “green” attention-grabbing feature – was a good idea in terms of additional complexity and cost.

Why so? Most cyclists don’t use their brakes very much overall, and if they do, it’s usually for only a very short period. The amount of kinetic energy available to be captured is also fairly small (KE = ½ mV2) – although I suspect that the regenerative feature was “free” with the existing hardware and only had a software cost.

But the biggest issue is the ruggedness of those bearings. They claimed the Wheel met and even exceeded the EN15194 standard for e-bikes, which requires IPX4 rating (splashproof, but not fully waterproof) but they actually designed it to meet more stringent IPX5 (low pressure water jet sprays but not fully waterproof). Still, stuff happens. (EN15194 is the strict European safety standard for Electrically Power-Assisted Cycles, or EPACs)

Replacing the bearings of a standard bicycle takes about 30 minutes with the right tools and has a parts cost about $30-$50. For the Copenhagen Wheel, the parts cost and associated repair labor (as it wasn’t a DIY repair in this case) were much, much higher.

This is unfortunately the reality of so many of today’s elegant products (yes, carmakers, I’m looking at you!): they are great when they work, but cost a small fortune to troubleshoot and fix. It’s a tradeoff that we are now increasingly forced to make.

When I checked the Web to get more information on the Copenhagen Wheel and its demise, there were users angry because their $1000 wheel is now useless, those who had had one and liked it, and those who loved it – the usual span of user assessment. Quite a few wished they could have kept theirs going, and some said they were lucky as their wheel was still working after all these years (only as long as they didn’t get a new phone or a downloaded a software upgrade to the one they had, that is!).

The tenacity of Copenhagen Wheel customers should not be underestimated. There’s a website that claims to show how to use an Arduino, with the right software, to un-brick the wheel, as well as unlocking code listings posted on various websites.

There’s a very clear lesson here for EEs working on innovative power-subsystems arrangements: no matter how good your intentions are, and despite countless simulations and evaluations of the electronics and algorithms alone, it’s the real hardware that can sink the project. Never underestimate the challenges of temperature, moisture, substandard components that didn’t meet promised specifications, and other real-world considerations on the viability and reliability of the product in the field.

As for me, I’ll stick with my fully non-electric, just hop on-and-go bike. Those who prefer to go electric can instead now buy a complete power-assist bike for $1000 to $2000, which is actually cheaper than the Copenhagen wheel, especially after taking 10 years of inflation into account – and that is also pretty amazing.

And I suggest the story of the rise, hype, development, and fall of the Copenhagen Wheel as a possible TV miniseries, as it has all the elements: “green” virtues, MIT connection, design challenges, frustrations, success, and eventual demise.

References:

  1. AutoDesk Instructables, “Build a Key for the Copenhagen Wheel With an ESP32 Microcontroller”
  2. Wikipedia, “Copenhagen Wheel”
  3. Reddit, “Die-hard Copenhagen Wheel Users unite!”
  4. ExtremeTech, “The Copenhagen Wheel turns any bicycle into an electric hybrid”
  5. The Vintagent, “The Current: The Copenhagen Wheel – An Instant E-Bike”
  6. Speed and Sprocket Cycle Works, “The Copenhagen Wheel”
  7. Senseable/MIT, “The Copenhagen Wheel”

—Bill Schweber is a degreed senior EE who has written three textbooks, hundreds of technical articles, opinion columns, and product features. Prior to becoming an author and editor, he spent his entire hands-on career on the analog side by working on power supplies, sensors and signal conditioning, and wired and wireless communication links. His work experience includes many years at Analog Devices in applications and marketing, and he also developed significant mechanical-engineering insight while designing control electronics for large materials-testing systems.

Related Content

  1. Are Solar-Powered Cars The Ultimate Electric Vehicles?
  2. Solar-powered cars: is it “déjà vu” all over again?
  3. What If Battery Progress Is Approaching Its End?
  4. Better EV battery packs: much more than “just” chemistry

The post When an energy-efficient design meets harsh reality appeared first on EDN.

20 November 2026
http://institutionofelectronics.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/IOE_LOGO.png 0 0 whdsolutions http://institutionofelectronics.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/IOE_LOGO.png whdsolutions2026-11-20 13:50:592026-11-20 13:50:59When an energy-efficient design meets harsh reality

Latest news

  • When an energy-efficient design meets harsh reality20 November 2026 - 13:50
  • Ensuring robust DOCSIS 3.1 or satellite coexistence with MoCA 2.519 November 2026 - 13:32
  • Are DC data centers the solution to AI scale?19 November 2026 - 07:26
  • Compact LEDs expand multi-color lighting options19 November 2026 - 01:23
  • Miniature actuator adds haptics to wearables19 November 2026 - 01:23
  • Infrared sensor takes aim at wearable health19 November 2026 - 01:23
  • LED drivers improve matrix scanning and dimming19 November 2026 - 01:23
  • Timing devices serve next-gen Ethernet and PCIe19 November 2026 - 01:23
  • Significantly simpler synchronous square wave circuit for frequency division by even numbers18 November 2026 - 13:16
  • Audio AI in wearables: Enabling smarter, more responsive devices18 November 2026 - 10:10
IOE LOGO 2

Become a member

click here

Become a member

click here

Become a subscriber

click here

Become a sponsor

click here

© Copyright - The Institution of Electronics | Website by WHD Solutions
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • Link to Facebook
  • Link to X
Link to: Ensuring robust DOCSIS 3.1 or satellite coexistence with MoCA 2.5 Link to: Ensuring robust DOCSIS 3.1 or satellite coexistence with MoCA 2.5 Ensuring robust DOCSIS 3.1 or satellite coexistence with MoCA 2.5
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top