Apple heads Home: Distributed identity validation, and how much does Matter matter?

Apple branding is front and center in the company’s resurrected smart home “push”. Although broader ecosystem compatibility is also feasible, you’d never know it from the messaging.

Within my 2024 CES coverage, I devoted a section to the industry-developed Matter smart home interoperability standard, which had originated in December 2019, as well as to the associated Thread wireless protocol. I was not encouraged by the then-current industry-adoption status, nor with the implementation robustness of what few implementations did exist, although I clung to a sliver of sooner-or-later “hope springs eternal” optimism.

The Matter smart home communication standard, built on the foundation of the Thread (based on Zigbee) wireless protocol, had no shortage of associated press releases and product demos in Las Vegas this week. But to date, its implementation has been underwhelming (leading to a scathing but spot-on recent diatribe from The Verge, among other pieces), both in comparison to its backers’ rosy projections and its true potential.

Not that any of this was a surprise to me, alas. Consider that the fundamental premise of Matter and Thread was to unite the now-fragmented smart home device ecosystem. If you’re an up-and-coming startup in the space, you love industry standards, because they lower your market-entry barriers versus larger, more established competitors. Conversely, if you’re one of those larger, more established suppliers, you love barriers to entry for your competitors.

Therefore the lukewarm-at-best (and more frequently, nonexistent or flat-out broken) embrace of Matter and Thread by legacy smart home technology and product suppliers. Suffice it to say that I’m skeptical about Matter and Thread’s long-term prospects, albeit only cautiously so. I just don’t know what it might take to break the logjam that understandably prevents competitors from working together, in spite of the reality that a rising tide often does end up lifting all boats…or if you prefer, it’s often better to get a slice of a large pie versus the entirety of a much smaller pie.

I’ve also appropriately scattered Matter and Thread mentions within a series of follow-up pieces, most notably my subsequent CES 2025 summary.

A year later, is the situation better? Not really, candidly. For a more in-depth supplier-sourced perspective, I encourage you to read Aalyia’s coverage of her time spent last week in Silicon Labs’ product suite, including an interview with Daniel Cooley, CTO of the company. Cooley is spot-on when he notes that “it is not unusual for standards adoption to progress slower than desired.” I’ve seen this same scenario play out plenty of times in the past, and Matter and Thread (assuming they eventually achieve widespread success) won’t be the last. I’m reminded, for example, of a quote attributed to Bill Gates, that “We always overestimate the change that will occur in the next two years and underestimate the change that will occur in the next 10.”

Cooley is also spot-on when he notes that Matter and Thread don’t necessarily need to go together; the Matter connectivity standard can alternatively use Ethernet (either wireless, aka Wi-Fi, or wired) for transport, along with Bluetooth Low Energy for initial device setup purposes. And granted, there has been at least some progress with both Matter (in particular) and Thread over the past year.

Version 1.4 of the Matter specification, announced last November, promises (quoting from Ars Technica’s coverage) “more device types, improvements for working across ecosystems [editor note: a concept called “Enhanced Multi-Admin”], and tools for managing battery backups, solar panels, and heat pumps”, for example. And at CES, the Connectivity Standards Alliance (CSA), which runs Matter, announced that Apple, Google, and Samsung will accept its certification results for their various “Works With” programs, too. That said, Amazon is notably absent from the CSA’s fast-track certification list

As I write these words in October 2026, we’re nearing two years since Matter 1.4’s release. The spec is now at the v1.6 level, with further enhancements including belated support for cameras and other sensors, along with energy management systems; you can read all the details at the associated Wikipedia entry. And speaking of Silicon Labs, for additional background info I’ll commend to your attention a still-relevant EDN article series published in early 2023 and authored by Rob Alexander, the company’s Principal Product Manager for Matter:

That all said, industry adoption still seems like it’s stuck in first gear, that is assuming it’s (arguably) moving forward at all. And specific to Apple, whose re-engagement with the smart home market went public earlier today, Matter seems to be little more than a convenient alternative means of achieving baseline access to Apple’s otherwise proprietary HomeKit ecosystem without need to pony up for a paid license, as was timely exemplified by yesterday’s TP-Link smart plug teardown. Indicative of this seeming irrelevance, Matter and Thread are mentioned only in passing in Apple’s press release covering partnerships with other companies.

Enter the brand-new HomeView

If I had to bet, I’d wager that the HomeView smart home hub has been stuck in the ready-for-production queue for a while now, awaiting a sufficiently robust AI-enhanced successor to the legacy Siri assistant service. The outcome product’s industrial design hearkens back to both Amazon’s latest-generation Echo Show series, released a year ago, and to Apple’s own 2002-2004 era iMac G4 computer.

Shown here is the product variant with a down-firing woofer and two passive radiators built into the base; a wall-mountable version with only the two 7” full-range drivers in the display is also available. Both cost $299, run an app-restricted operating system also branded HomeView, functionally reminiscent of the Apple Watch UI and with an intriguing derivative-of-CarPlay angle, and are based on the Apple Silicon A18 SoC; the DRAM size wasn’t announced (although in the iPhone SoC variant, it’s 8 GBytes). And there’s zero mention of Matter or Thread anywhere in the press release this time, although on-site media inquiries revealed that HomeView can in fact act as both a Matter controller and bridge, along with as a Thread border router.

The above conceptual usage promo video is admittedly compelling (IMHO, at least); I’ll cover shortly the privacy ramifications and implementation of the multi-user scenario shown in it.

Evolutionary advancements also garner announcements

The HomePod mini smart speaker was originally introduced in October 2020, with more colors added to the product line mix a year later (and a teardown by yours truly ~1.5 years after that), so a redesign was arguably overdue. We didn’t get much today, but it was at least something. The SoC inside is now the S10, versus the prior S5, both originally intended for various Apple Watch generations and this time Apple Intelligence-capable.

Then there’s the Apple TV 4K, the newest generation of which candidly and bafflingly seems to have been cut off at the knees by its creator on day one. Its SoC upgrade from the A15 Bionic in the 2022 version of the device to the A18 affords it AI capabilities…but Apple’s also bringing Siri AI to both the 2022 and 2021 versions of the device (presumably predominantly cloud processing-based in these older, latter cases), so if you already own one, you’re good. The newest version embeds a three-microphone array that lets you shout at it from afar…but the remote controls included with legacy Apple TV 4K versions already embed a microphone.

And speaking of remote controls, the newest Apple TV 4K’s version embeds a speaker so you can prompt it to emit a locating sound if it’s stuck between the cushions of your sofa…but that same remote control can also be purchased separately for $59 for use with legacy Apple TV 4K versions. And did I mention that the newest Apple TV 4K costs $299, both a $50 uptick from the current price of its equivalent-capacity predecessor (which itself saw a $100 price increase from the original $149 earlier this year) and twice the price of Google’s TV Streamer 4K (which itself is notably pricier than equivalents from Roku, Walmart, and the like)? The only other notable benefit that the newest Apple TV 4K affords is integrated stereo and surround sound support, but actualizing this particular aspiration necessitates one or two matched pairs of only second-generation HomePods and/or HomePod minis.

Privacy-assuring redundancy

Wrapping up, the aspect of today’s announcements that I actually found most interesting was what Apple referred to at the end of the HomeView press release as “Private and Secure by Design” and I alluded to by the “Distributed identity validation” mention in this piece’s title.

If you haven’t yet seen the conceptual usage promo video I embedded earlier, please go back and watch it before continuing. Two things you’ll likely note straightaway are that:

The HomeView device dynamically recognizes each user audibly by voice and/or visibly by face, and
The HomeView device responded by dynamically tailoring its UI to each user’s preferences as well as more generally by replying using that user’s dataset.

Voice and face recognition are admittedly getting more responsive and reliable all the time, but they’re still not perfect. The latter’s not even an option with the camera-less HomePod mini v2 and 2026 iteration of the Apple TV 4K. And when you’re dealing with a user’s personal information—emails and text messages, calendar and contacts data, music and image libraries, etc.—you need to be absolutely sure of who you believe you’re interacting with, no matter that you’re presumably interacting with someone who lives in the home where the device is located.

That’s why personalized AI is only available on today’s announced devices for users who:

Have registered Apple accounts, and
Have unlocked FaceID-capable iPhones (translation: not the latest iPhone Duo, for example) and iPads logged into those accounts and either connected to the same Wi-Fi network as the HomeView, HomePod mini v2 and/or 2026-version Apple TV 4K, or recently on Wi-Fi but currently logged in via cellular (I’m assuming this latter exception handles cases where someone’s iPad or iPhone briefly drops Wi-Fi).

It also, of course, conveniently excludes Android smartphone and tablet owners and the like. Ahem.

That’s “all” I’ve got for you today. Rumors suggest that Apple’s got another event scheduled for two weeks from today. We’ll see; if so, I’ll see you back here then. For now, as always, I welcome your thoughts in the comments!

—Brian Dipert is the associate editor, as well as a contributing editor, at EDN.

Apple heads Home: Distributed identity validation, and how much does Matter matter?

Enter the brand-new HomeView

Evolutionary advancements also garner announcements

Privacy-assuring redundancy

Become a member

Become a member

Become a subscriber

Become a sponsor